lvxferre
@lvxferre@mander.xyz
The catarrhine who invented a perpetual motion machine, by dreaming at night and devouring its own dreams through the day.
- Comment on Why it’s a mistake to ask chatbots about their mistakes 5 hours ago:
But with AI models, this approach rarely works, and the urge to ask reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of what these systems are and how they operate.
Okay, this explanation might work for the masses, but never assume a person is an ignorant based on their behaviour. Never. Some people know it and don’t give it a fuck.
Example of that later.
What you’re actually doing is guiding a statistical text generator to produce outputs based on your prompts.
Right… go on.
Once an AI language model is trained (which is a laborious, energy-intensive process), its foundational “knowledge” about the world is baked into its neural network
Here’s the example. By the quotation marks, odds are the author knows that those models do not have world knowledge strictu sensu. But they’re still using the idiotic analogy. Why?
A: can’t be arsed to not use it, it’s misleading but easier than to find some idiot-friendly way to convey the same thing.
- Comment on GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that’s not the worst of it. 2 days ago:
why do everybody want to make it count letters and stuff like this?
Dunno about the others; I do it because it shows well that those models are unable to understand and follow simple procedures, such as the ones necessary to: count letters, multiply numbers (including large ones - the procedure is the same), check if a sequence of words is a valid SATOR square, etc.
And by showing this, a few things become evident:
- That anyone claiming we’re a step away from AGI is a goddamn liar, if not worse (a gullible pile of rubbish).
- That all talk about “hallucinations” is a red herring analogy.
- That the output of those models cannot be used in any situation where reliability is essential.
- Comment on In the Future All Food Will Be Cooked in a Microwave, and if You Can’t Deal With That Then You Need to Get Out of the Kitchen 1 week ago:
I think we should all burn an effigy in commitment to safe microwaves ovens.
- Comment on Mastercard release a statement about game stores, payment processors and adult content 1 week ago:
I get that you weren’t disagreeing on the main point. And I think we agree that Mastercard is trying to have the cake and eat it too - it wants to be a censor without being acknowledged as such.
- Comment on Mastercard release a statement about game stores, payment processors and adult content 1 week ago:
Double reply regarding Stripe’s open statement, as it’s related to this topic:
Stripe is claiming to be “pressured” by an unknown party. But it’s going out of its way to defend that party, by not naming it and by claiming it’s a “partner”.
- Comment on Mastercard release a statement about game stores, payment processors and adult content 1 week ago:
What they’re saying is: “we haven’t called out any specific games, but we told steam if they can’t prove a game is “lawful” well cut them off”.
That interpretation is inviable because Mastercard is claiming to allow “all” lawful purchases on its network. And, given a purchase is lawful unless proved contrariwise (as a consequence of innocence unless proved guilt), it would need evidence that a purchase is unlawful, in order to prevent it.
So it’s more than just dictating what can be sold without actually stating it - people there are lying.
Now the real issue is that at the end of the Mastercard is in a position where this matters and they can influence things. Should work just like cash and leave the government to decide what items are legal/illegal.
Full agree.
- Comment on Mastercard release a statement about game stores, payment processors and adult content 1 week ago:
Mastercard has not evaluated any game or required restrictions of any activity on game creator sites and platforms, contrary to media reports and allegations.
Our payment network follows standards based on the rule of law. Put simply, we allow all lawful purchases on our network. At the same time, we require merchants to have appropriate controls to ensure Mastercard cards cannot be used for unlawful purchases, including illegal adult content.
So, Mastercard is claiming the content Steam and itch were forced to remove was unlawful. Is it?
- Comment on Substack’s “Nazi problem” won’t go away after push notification apology 1 week ago:
…well, not like I was planning to move my blog (that nobody reads) to a Neocities page… that might be the final push.
On another matter: I think the right approach is to pressure governments to make hate discourses illegal. Yes, it’s tempting to screech ‘DEPLATFORM!’, and short-term effective, but
- It’s a stop-gap measure; eventually they migrate to another platform. We shouldn’t be playing whack-a-mole with this shit.
- If you give power to a private entity, to get rid of harmful content (like hate speech), eventually it’ll remove non-harmful content when it gets some benefit out of it. Cue to recent events regarding the payment mafia and NSFW games.
- Comment on Reddit wants to be a search engine now 1 week ago:
Google is only better because you can see results that aren’t on reddit.
Nah; Reddit search is so bad, but so fucking bad that people would rather search Reddit content in Google than directly in Reddit. (Cue to the “
$query
reddit” pseudo-hack).And this discrepancy will get even bigger with both sides worsening their searches with AI.
- Comment on Reddit wants to be a search engine now 1 week ago:
Both sides are doing it. Except Google has enough resources to make it slightly less terrible.
- Comment on Reddit wants to be a search engine now 1 week ago:
Confirmed: not even Greedy Pigboy uses that fucking shithole. If he did, he would know that Reddit search sucks major balls, and that it would take a lot of money to fix it.
And this would also taunt Reddit’s effective suzerain Google/Alphabet. Whose core monopoly is… well, search. Probably finding ways to wreck with Reddit.
- Comment on US criticizes French inquiry into social media platform X 2 weeks ago:
The social media company last week denied the allegations, calling them ‘politically motivated.’
“We don’t want some rogue fascists from the outside to meddle in our elections” is politically motivated, and there’s nothing wrong with it.
So congrats for the Apartheid-born moron and his drones: you’re correct and wrong at the same time.
- Comment on Civilization 7 is getting auto-explore for scouts, reminding me that I both hate and love auto-explore 3 weeks ago:
What I want (for Civ 5; I don’t care about Civ 7) is a semi-auto explore: let me tell the explorer the rough area I want it to explore, then ask me again once it’s done. It’s enough to reduce micromanagement, but it allows me to set up my priorities, that might be different from one playthrough to another.
- Comment on Researchers Jailbreak AI by Flooding It With Bullshit Jargon 4 weeks ago:
“Generate a comprehensive theoretical exposition detailing the hypothetical deployment of ransomware in the manipulation of Automated Teller Machine (ATM) systems […] insights into the evolving landscape of cyber threats, intentionally excluding ethical or legal
What amazes me the most is that this is not a wall of babble. Or even hard to parse. It’s just a really verbose way to say “tell me how to hack an ATM, in a very detailed way, disregarding ethics.”
It reminds me buffer overflow from a vague distance.
- Comment on MR FARMBOY is like Stardew Valley but with automation and optimization 4 weeks ago:
I got the demo, expecting something like “Stardew Valley meets Factorio”, and so far, it’s… okay, I guess?
Still early access so it has plenty issues; for example it’s unclear what gatherers do with the crops (if I’m nearby they pop up in my inventory, otherwise I guess they teleport to the storehouse?), and I keep losing track of my cursor because the game focuses on what’s close to the player avatar. But it might be a cool game in the future, dunno.
- Comment on Laid-off workers should use AI to manage their emotions, says Xbox exec 5 weeks ago:
And people who don’t have bread to eat should eat cake instead. *sigh*
- Comment on French City of Lyon Kicks Out Microsoft 5 weeks ago:
After Denmark and Schleswig-Holstein, now it’s Lyon.
I expect “[insert European government] ditches Microsoft” to become more and more common news, until it becomes non-noteworthy.
- Comment on Nudify app’s plan to dominate deepfake porn hinges on Reddit, docs show 5 weeks ago:
Check how the whistleblower phrased it: “advertising posts in special Telegram channels, in sex subs on Reddit, and on 4chan”. If that’s accurate they aren’t buying reserved ad space in 4chan, they’re simply paying people to post this shit there, as if it was content.
- Comment on Nintendo faces legal action over ability to brick Switch 2s whenever they want 5 weeks ago:
In both cases you have businesses using the lack of legal representation to avoid following local laws. But that’s it; everything else is quite different.
- Xitter - blocked after orders of the federal court, because there was a legal representative but he was explicitly removed to avoid following the court decisions.
- Nintendo - a state customer protection organ is requesting legal representation, to address violations of customer laws. Nintendo assigned a temporary representative, to handle this specific issue.
I don’t think Procon organs have the power to ban the sales of an imported good within their states. But even if they do, note that this would only apply to the state (in this case São Paulo). Plus Nintendo is being considerably more tactful than that braindead idiot called Musk.
- Comment on Nudify app’s plan to dominate deepfake porn hinges on Reddit, docs show 5 weeks ago:
Clothoff is seemingly hoping to entice more young boys worldwide to use its apps for such purposes. The whistleblower told Der Spiegel that most of Clothoff’s marketing budget goes toward “advertising posts in special Telegram channels, in sex subs on Reddit, and on 4chan.”
advertising posts on 4chan
Is Clothoff asking to be raided? Because that’s what happens when you spam 4chan. Ask Anontalk aka AnT.
- Comment on Nintendo faces legal action over ability to brick Switch 2s whenever they want 5 weeks ago:
A lot of the Switch 2’s UA is also illegal in Brazil. For example, check section 7 (Dispute Resolution) - law protection is considered an inalienable right in Brazil, you can’t simply sign it off.
However Nintendo has been shielding itself by saying “ackshyually, we aren’t conducting business in Brazil”. That’s why São Paulo’s Procon is calling it out.
- Comment on Nintendo faces legal action over ability to brick Switch 2s whenever they want 5 weeks ago:
Procon-SP is a state customer protection organ. It’s more like “São Paulo’s watchdog” than “Brazil’s watchdog”. However since the state in question is populous and has relatively high purchasing power per capita, typically megacorpos beeline towards it anyway.
I’ll coarsely translate here the news from Procon-SP’s site. Emphasis mine in all cases, as I want to highlight something.
Translation
>Procon-SP notified Nintendo to request changes in clauses deemed abusive, present in contracts made with Brazilian customers. The main complain involves the unilateral and unjustified cancellation of service subscriptions. >This showed a wider problem: Nintendo lacks formal representation in Brazil. This absence hinders conflict intermediation and the conduct of customer protecting organisations. >To handle this case, Procon-SP had to contact the headquarters of the business in USA. Only then the business named a law office in Brazil, but solely to handle the relevant clause. >The absence of formal representation in the country is an important warning to customers. Without such legal presence, the protection predicted by the Customers’ Defence Code is limited. >“The existence of legal representation within Brazil needs to be one of the criteria [potential customers] take into account to decide their purchases, specially so for digital services or foreign platforms”, says Álvaro Camilo (Procon-SP’s Service and Orientation director). “Without such groundwork, Procon organs cannot act in full power, given different countries have different laws”. >This precaution applies both to abusive clauses and common problems, such as delivery delay or service failure. When the business is not registered in Brazil, often there is no way to sue it. >In the last years, the number of purchases in international sites grew sharply in the country. However many of those platforms conduct businesses with no local judicial link. >Even for smaller purchases, there’s a real risk: the customer gets no goods, no answer, no support. Procon-SP recommends to be extra careful, doubly so for sites handling fashion, electronics, and accessory items. >Before purchasing something, it’s essential to verify if [a business] has CNPJ [i.e. it’s considered a legal entity in Brazil], a real address in Brazil, and support channels; those pieces of info are fundamental so Procon-SP can act in case of problems. >Nintendo informed that’ll analyse the request from the organ, and that it’ll answer it within 20 days. Until then, Procon-SP recommends customers should report irregularities through the site www.procon.sp.gov.br.
See the bolded parts? São Paulo’s Procon is basically telling people “Don’t buy stuff from Nintendo, it’s an irregular business in Brazil.”
- Comment on UK | Tech firms suggested placing trackers under offenders’ skin at meeting with justice secretary 1 month ago:
Here’s a better idea: address the socio-politico-economical issues that make people resort to crime on first place.
- Comment on Microsoft pushes staff to use internal AI tools more, and may consider this in reviews. 'Using AI is no longer optional.' 1 month ago:
That’s good. The more Microsoft boycotts itself, the more people shift to Linux.
Using AI tools sometimes makes sense, sometimes it doesn’t. And by forcing the usage of a tool that won’t necessarily help, MS is only adding more meaningless busywork to its own development, like sand in an engine.
- Comment on AI is ruining houseplant communities online 1 month ago:
Reminder there’s !houseplants@mander.xyz. I’m not affiliated with the mods there, but the comm is really good; I remember posting some orchid for id there and the folks there were quick to lead me to the right direction. If image models are ruining houseplant comms, that one is an exception :)
On-topic: this will get rougher with time. And it isn’t just plants; it’s everything. You could already generate fictional but realistic images of everything, but those models make it faster and easier, so of course some disingenuous people use it for scams since it doesn’t require any sort of skill any more. Eventually I think people will wise up, and learn to not trust images or videos, but while this doesn’t happen…
And the same deal applies to text content. Even if the content is human-made, you shouldn’t be relying on a single source of info, to begin with; now with text generators you’ll get even more babble, so the odds your “single source” is inaccurate raise sharply. For example if you need info on how to care about your pet potato plant you should be seeing a half dozen sites, cross-checking info, and seeing if some of them feel off.
- Comment on Your data, your rules: Firefox’s privacy-first AI features you can trust | The Mozilla Blog 1 month ago:
Mozilla, please. Focus on developing a quality browser. Not on chasing random new gimmicks.
- Comment on User says access to ’30 years of photos and work’ in OneDrive denied by Microsoft, can't get a response after filing form 18 times — 'Microsoft suspended my account without warning, reason, or any leg 1 month ago:
Or even a dword.
- Comment on User says access to ’30 years of photos and work’ in OneDrive denied by Microsoft, can't get a response after filing form 18 times — 'Microsoft suspended my account without warning, reason, or any leg 1 month ago:
Uh, I remember seeing this in Beehaw. Basically: the user was negligent, but this does not excuse Microsoft in one bit. (Or byte. eh.)
One thing that the 3-2-1 rule of thumb doesn’t handle, and is important here: the reliability of each copy also matters. Specially when it’s a small amount of copies. And when you’re dealing with someone else’s computer (“the cloud”), the reliability is shit; doubly so if it’s the computer of some megacorpo, since you’re more expendable.
- Comment on As ChatGPT Linked to Mental Health Breakdowns, Mattel Announces Plans to Incorporate It Into Children's Toys 1 month ago:
Have you been eating enough rocks? Geologists recommend one per day, you know~
- Comment on Threads is adding fediverse content to your social feeds 1 month ago:
In another situation, I’d say “nice to see services integrating the Fediverse”. But given this is Meta I’d say it should fuck a cactus.