Comment on Valve’s New Steam Deck Framerate Data Does More Harm Than Good
pathief@lemmy.world 4 days agoThe graph helps but, like you said, it is yet another click away. Before you see the graph you’re already conditioned by the “42 FPS average” information. You see the FPS dipping in the graph but you’ll think that’s an outlier. The average is 42 FPS after all, that’s nice amirite.
Personally, I feel like the solution is that the Steam Verified badge should mean something. Solid 30 FPS should be the golden standard. If the game is frequently at 15-20 FPS then it should be “Playable”, not “Verified”. The current criteria where typing your name with a virtual keyboard means “Playable” but running at 15 FPS is “Verified” is not helpful.
These charts are good for those games that are incorrectly marked as borked or don’t have a verified status. You can now see that evidence that people are playing the game, and that’s nice.
thingsiplay@lemmy.ml 4 days ago
I assume because it is in Beta stage. My hope is, that there is a setting in Steam to enable or disable this graph directly on the game page (in web browser and in the client).
It actually means something. When the Steam Deck launched, an employee explained it means something like “the game should run like it would if this was on similar hardware playing on Windows”, from performance standpoint. And off course it should be an experience like a native console game with default settings working right away. Also the “playable” and “acceptable” tolerance is different for everyone.
And that’s the key point, it should behave like on consoles. I mean games on console are basically verified for that system, right? I mean any game you can purchase on Playstation 4 is verified for that system. It does not make any guarantees about performance or quality. And this is how I view the verification too. There are extreme cases, but that’s not what we talk about.
Some would argue, 40 FPS should be the golden standard on Deck in example, instead 30. There are games which have a hard time to stay at 30 FPS, like Baldur’s Gate 3, but are played a lot of the system.
pathief@lemmy.world 4 days ago
It doesn’t matter what a Dev said a long time ago, it matters what they advertise. They advertise that a steam deck verified game “performs well on the Steam deck”. I know well is a broad term, but anything less than solid 30FPS should be immediately “Playable”.
Games like Final Fantasy 16 that frequently dip to 15 FPS cannot be marked as Verified. If they handed these badges correctly, there wouldn’t be a need for community based fps history or even protondb.
thingsiplay@lemmy.ml 4 days ago
It matters, because that is an explanation to how it works. This (what I explained) explains it well. If you choose to ignore the logic, then all your argumentation makes no sense. Because you ignore what the verification actually means.
Which is inline with what I said. It does not contradict to what the developer said.
I strongly disagree. First it depends on what game. For a fighting game like Street Fighter or Tekken where all versions of the game MUST be 60 FPS to be on the same playing field, I can understand that 30 FPS leads to just a “Playable” rating. But if we talk about a strategy game like Civilization where FPS is not that important, or maybe a JRPG like Final Fantasy, a 30 FPS should not lead to just being Playable rating. That would be wrong.
Just because it sometimes goes below the mark does not disqualify the Verified rating. As explained in my previous reply. I think many (including you) misunderstand the Verification system with a Quality or Performance system. If the game however is constantly below 30 FPS and the FPS is crucial for the game, then I would understand it. But dipping here and there does not disqualify in my opinion. I think Valve handles the verification correctly.
pathief@lemmy.world 4 days ago
It doesn’t matter because consumers aren’t going to hunt for Dev statements from years ago. They click the badge, the badge explains the criteria and that should be it.
I’m not saying all games with 30 fps should be verified. I’m saying all games below 30 fps should not be deck verified. That’s a very different statement.
You say I misunderstand the badge as a quality/performance metric but that is exactly what they say it is. I’m quoting them.