Dnb@lemmy.dbzer0.com 5 days ago
This is purely from a broken test. Watch the video and you’ll see that its not testing with the same power limits.
17w tests are actually 16w vs 20w+ and 35w test is 25w vs 35w
This leads to drastically higher clock speeds on both cpu and gpu as seen in the video and thus higher fps (and power draw, so lower battery life)
Please help stop the spread of misinformation
Fubarberry@sopuli.xyz 5 days ago
Good catch, results didn’t seem suspicious because Linux has had major performance improvements over windows on previous handhelds.
Dnb@lemmy.dbzer0.com 5 days ago
I’m also suspicious of those tests since they don’t show details like power usage. Same problem Tom’s did here, took the data at face value missing the clear signs in the original video showing how it was tested improperly.
There are many tweaks and bugs like 17w being 20w+ with this version of the os.
Fubarberry@sopuli.xyz 5 days ago
Here’s another video on it that goes more in depth: youtu.be/CJXp3UYj50Q
Basically the SteamOS version gets better fps in most games while also have way better battery life. Lower power games would get 2x the battery life when fps when both versions were targeting the same settings/fps.
Basically windows naturally has more overhead than Linux, which really impacts performance/battery life in low power games. But vulkan also typically outperforms directX, so many directX see a noticable performance increase on SteamOS as well (although some amount of this performance gain can be had on windows as well by using dxvk).
Dnb@lemmy.dbzer0.com 5 days ago
I’ll take a look later but quick check he is using two different devices which means its not identical hardware/ firmware.
Also there are many many many more cases where performance has been the same
reddit.com/…/better_game_performance_on_windows_o…
And countless others who see no difference between windows and Linux.
Most times if there is is due to dxvk / Proton fixing a game bug/bottleneck, or invalid testing with not identical settings/hardware.
There is no way windows is using more power and giving lower clock rates without some other bug effecting it.
houjou@jlai.lu 5 days ago
https://youtu.be/OwWRCrGoXV0?t=284 Digital Foundry tested few games and found no significative differences. But it’s still a big win for linux gaming since those game aren’t native.