Comment on The TikTok Ban Paradox: How Platform Restrictions Create What They Aim to Prevent
hendrik@palaver.p3x.de 3 days ago
Really? They claim various things with a lot of certainty. But all they do is speculate... If it's that obvious, why isn't there any precedent or fact to back it up? I mean comparing it to the situation in a different country, about a different topic is quite a stretch. And to my knowledge, it's not even in place yet. So there shouldn't be any results to compare?!
UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 3 days ago
Given the number of internet services that have been targeted for censorship or banning (Pornhub, anyone selling contraceptives across state lines, digital libraries like the Internet Archive) they’re going to be encouraged to learn.
Plenty of TikTok content creators have been working “How to get my content once the service has been banned” explainers into their feeds. And its not like this is a revolutionary new technology or one that’s difficult to implement on your machine.
hendrik@palaver.p3x.de 3 days ago
I mean the VPN providers themselves (at least some) have been quite busy promoting their services. For years already. NordVPN ads run on TV, at times every other Youtube video was "sponsored by NordVPN". So people should know about their existence.
But... It would be a massive surprise to me if the average user was going to change their habits. I've been telling people constantly not to give their flashlight app access to contacts, location and full administrator privileges. Told them to pay attention to their freedom and maybe not sell their soul to big tech if there's nice and lovely mail providers which have a foot massage ready for you for $1 a month. People don't care and they won't listen. They'll ask me "Yeah, but why don't you just WhatsApp and GMail?"
I see no way this is going to change, and they'll now suddenly pick up to fight for their freedom. I think that's a niche for some few Linux nerds. I'd be very happy, though, if I was wrong and they do...
UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 3 days ago
Visiting TikTok every time you’re bored isn’t a habit?
Some of this stuff is functionally non-negotiable, at least from a practical perspective. If your OS is harvesting your data, there’s only so much you can do without completely rooting the device. If the only way to access the internet is by signing up with a satanic ISP, you’re not simply going to go without and still function in a modern economy.
But this isn’t businesses doing “Treats with Strings Attached”. This is nanny state conservatives putting up relatively easily evaded barriers to said treats in order to tell their paleocon base that the problem of pornography in their state has been solved.
I see things changing day by day. Just not in the direction I’d prefer.
But there’s always a breaking point, there’s always a backlash, and these institutions only have a reach up to the scale of human labor they’re willing to commit tot he task
hendrik@palaver.p3x.de 3 days ago
I mean you could just install Signal instead of WhatsApp. Takes literally the same effort.
I get your point. It's valid. I still think it's not going to happen. It'll be either to complicated, or there will be other brain-rot content available someplace else. Or it's going to be the boiling frog syndrome. One tiny freedom after another will dissapear. Maybe there's still porn on xhamster available. So it's not that big a deal. And nobody will notice the subtle change. And one day it'll just be the world without porn, free speech, but with total surveillance. I really believe we can get there without any uprising if we make the steps small enough.
We'll see. As I said, I'm not overly enthusiastic. But it's speculation and I might be wrong.
homesweethomeMrL@lemmy.world 3 days ago
It also ensure those who don’t pay are tracked by default, which is a key component of not having privacy.