Submitted 1 month ago by BrikoX@lemmy.zip to gaming@lemmy.zip
https://www.techspot.com/news/104889-pc-gaming-fan-steven-spielberg-cant-do-controllers.html
The director of Raiders of the Lost Ark, E.T., Jurassic Park, and many more classics has long spoken about his love of video games, stretching back to 1982 when he revealed the instant thrill and ego “massage” that playing games like Donkey Kong and Tempest provided.
Guys, it really depends on the type of game.
Random celebrity has opinion: news at 11.
That’s no random celebrity, that’s The Director.
Of BoomBlox obviously
I don’t care that his work has made me ugly cry in awe of profound humanity, he’s a random celebrity on this subject.
Name checks out
He really is a videogame fan. When he co-created DreamWorks he pushed for a gaming arm of the company. If anyone played Metal of Honor (especially the first one) it’s because of him.
Also, ET helped cause the videogame crash in the 80’s!
The d day level of medal of honor was a serious moment. It's like "yeah, you keep dying and it's frustrating. You're watching all these other people die. But that's what it was actually like."
There was a moment where I had made it to the buildings and looked back and saw my brothers in arms being mowed down and it's a different experience than seeing it on TV.
Yep, one of the most memorable levels in a video game ever
And he’s right too
It depends on the game.
Trying to play a platformer using a keyboard is miserable. On the flip-side, trying to play an RTS with a controller sounds like one of the worst experiences imaginable.
it’s only miserable if the developer doesn’t care about mkb.
Analog sticks beat WSAD for movement any day and the mouse beats analog sticks in aiming.
Different tools for the job.
There are keyboards with hall-effect/magnetic switches that allow precise measurement of how much any given key is held down. With that said it’s be possible to map the signals from WASD to emulate a controller’s left stick (at least in games that allow simultaneous kb+m and controller inputs, but that’s fairly common in my experience).
I have a keyboard like that on pre-order and I’m definitely looking forward to trying it. 4mm of travel isn’t much, but it should still be better than a binary signal.
nah
(and thus another 20 page long argument about gamepads and kb+m was started on the interwebs)
Controller is more comfortable to me, so unless I’m playing an fps that requires a lot of precision, I play on controller. I already have to sit at a mouse and keyboard for work everyday
He wrote E.T on a spilt keyboard in vim and managed to exit it first time… True story John Candy told me.
<…> managed to exit it first time <…>
That is not possible…
I really hate how many people haven’t really picked up or understood the profound difference that gyro aiming makes for controller players.
C’mon valve make a steam controller 2
I need everyone and their mothers to learn how to use Steam Input, lets me easy set up any game for Gyro on the Deck. For example, if I have my thumb on the right track pad, it’ll make the gyro much more precise, which makes aiming much nicer
Gyros are absolutely key going forward
Pretty much why my Xbox is on a shelf.
I much prefer controller for anything that’s not FPS. Steam Input makes this glorious.
I want to make love to Steam Input
That’s an interesting perspective.
to each their own.
Maybe he knows where all the unsold E.T. carts are buried.
We all know, they were found and partially excavated in 2014 for a documentary
I had the same problem, having never used a console. I’ve always been using PCs (starting with small 8 bit machines, to a 286, and later to the beasts we currently use (running Linux though). It took me a good while to get used to the Steam deck.
I had no choice because I have no other gaming rig at the moment while my home is being completely rebuilt, so my PC has been turned off for two years now :(.
I’ve gotten better at it, and I’m getting through Fallout on the deck, but I have to avoid some games. For while some games do indeed work better with a controller, others (FPS) are way better with keyboard and mouse.
So all in all, I’m glad that the Deck has opened new possibilities. But the game controller isn’t the ultimate gadget, just another option.
I can handle any action game, platformer, etc. using a controller, despite heavily preferring a keyboard and mouse. I still can’t play FPS/TPS games on a controller… it has to be m&k.
I’m in the same camp, although I wish it wasn’t so. I’ve gotten okayish at Rocket League with mouse and keyboard, but that really is a controller game.
Oh yeah. Had exactly the same experience. Thought I was doing OK for a while but came to realise that there are some things that are white hard to do in that game with mouse and kb
A controller was designed to play with it. Keyboard and mouse were not. People got used to it.
Funny, the game I most associate with him is BoomBlox on the Wii. It’s a really great game, and I guess the wiimote is kind of mouse-like, particularly in that game.
He’s been involved in several games though, even had an office at EA for a while. Most famously, of course, is the original Medal of Honor. Arguably the success of MoH as a franchise led directly to Call of Duty and thus to the current state of gaming today.
The only controller I’ve ever really enjoyed using is the steam controller. Just about everything else felt worse than playing using a mouse and keyboard. To each their own though, if you like controllers then more power to you.
Its excellent for certain types of games but the lack of a right joystick made it useless with the vast majority.
I mean like “oh no, I’m being shot from behind, just give me 5 seconds to swipe 6 times on this touchpad and line up a shot”
It could totally be setup to feel/work like a trackball, remember playing a bunch of warframe with mine and being able to “throw” it and have it stop when you touch the pad again, took getting used to but substantially more flexible than a regular analogue stick.
oh no, I’m being shot from behind, just give me 5 seconds to hold my joystick all the way to the edge and line up a shot
I agree that the touchpad isn’t best for every game, but your example just sounds like your sensitivity is way too low. I used to have a couple steam controllers, I have a steam deck, and I used to play a lot of mobile shooters before I could afford a pc. In any case, I like my sensitivity to be 1 full swipe = 180° in game. Add in gyro and I’ll make that about 1-to-1 device rotation to in-game rotation (or if anything a little more sensitive).
Not quite the same, but I set up my steam deck’s right track pad to be a flick stick, turn around 180° with a flick. (And gyroscope)
I don’t play any multiplayer games, so this could be considered cheating, but it’s too nice to not use
Took me the longest time to get used to controllers as well. I’m pleased that o know how to use both though. Each scheme is the best at something
I go the opposite. I have been console gaming for 40 years. I can perform much better even in fps games while on a controller
With auto aim off?
Yup. Controllers just work better for me. I have fast reaction time. I beat the Battletoads speeder level!
I like both depending but M/KB are my favorite most of the time.
terraborra@lemmy.nz 1 month ago
Based.
In all seriousness some games work better on controllers. I’ve found it much easier, and significantly less frustrating, to play souls-likes using a controller. It also would have been next to impossible to play the Ascent (twin stick shooter) without one. I used to get all PCMR about only using keyboard and mouse but nowadays I use the best tool for the job.
degen@midwest.social 1 month ago
Oh I played the hell out of the Prepare to Die edition of Dark Souls. Keyboard and mouse was the objectively wrong way to play the game lmao
terraborra@lemmy.nz 1 month ago
Haha what an absolute masochist! I’m impressed.
I played through Jedi: Fallen Order, which was my intro into the genre, then tried it for Elden Ring and got hard stuck in the opening area. Still pretty useless at them overall but no longer feel like I’m battling against the control. It’s 100% just a skill issue.
Benaaasaaas@lemmy.world 1 month ago
Well it’s only because from software did a really shit job at porting the game. Elden Ring plays fine with the mouse and keyboard.
Cadeillac@lemmy.world 1 month ago
I played Grand Theft Auto V with both. KB&M on foot, controller for vehicles
Rai@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 month ago
Saaaame! Vehicles are so much better with a controller, but aiming suuuuucks with a controller.
umbrella@lemmy.ml 1 month ago
pcmr means you have the choice of which works best for the job instead of being stuck with a specific controller or ms+kb
steal_your_face@lemmy.ml 1 month ago
I feel like everything besides shooters and rts is better on controller. I can’t play an fps with a controller though.
undeffeined@lemmy.ml 1 month ago
My first souls game was Dark Souls 2. Played it with keyboard and mouse and only found out you can lock onto enemies about 100 hours in…
Malgas@beehaw.org 1 month ago
Then you get things like GTA or Saints Row, where whether I want to be using kb+m or controller changes based on whether I’m driving or on foot.
I’ve long thought that the ideal control scheme would somehow incorporate both a mouse for camera control, the sheer number of buttons you get from having your off-hand on a keyboard, and also analog inputs for things like movement/steering and vehicle throttle.
Hazmatastic@lemm.ee 1 month ago
They have left-hand hardware that has a thumb analog stick and a bunch of mapable keys. Problem is getting games to use “controller” functions like analog sticks and mouse functions at the same time. I haven’t tried it myself, but apparently most games don’t have a way to recognize and use that as a keyboard function
phdepressed@sh.itjust.works 1 month ago
I play rocket league with a keyboard and mouse. Have gotten up to champ in 2v2 and 3v3 ranked.
Also beat ds1 and 2 using keyboard and mouse.
In other words git gud.